The Sorcerer’s Apprentice 2 (2026) Plot Hypotheses

Although The Sorcerer’s Apprentice 2 has not been officially confirmed, fans are still hoping for a sequel that will expand the magical world of Balthazar Blake (Nicolas Cage) and his apprentice Dave Stutler (Jay Baruchel). If Disney decides to make a sequel, the plot could revolve around the following theories:

The Sorcerer’s Apprentice 2 (2026)

1. The journey to find Chernabog – a more dangerous enemy than Morgana
In the first film, Balthazar Blake and Dave Stutler defeated the dark witch Morgana le Fay, stopping her plans to rule the world. However, in legend, Morgana is not the only evil force. A potential sequel could introduce Chernabog – a legendary creature and one of the most powerful witches to ever exist.

Chernabog first appeared in the Night on Bald Mountain scene of the 1940 animated film Fantasia, where he was portrayed as a powerful evil spirit with the power to control darkness and the souls of the dead. In The Sorcerer’s Apprentice 2, Chernabog may be awakened by a group of dark wizards left behind from the Morganians. When he awakens, Balthazar and Dave will have to find a way to stop him before he plunges the world into eternal darkness.

2. Dave Stutler Perfects His Role as the “True Sorcerer”
In the first film, Dave started out as a clumsy physics student, but gradually became a talented sorcerer under Balthazar’s training. However, he has yet to reach his full potential.

The sequel could focus on Dave facing the greatest challenge of his sorcerer career – a task that even Balthazar could not handle. To win, Dave needs to overcome his own limitations, discover his hidden powers, and possibly develop a completely new type of magic, combining science and magic.

3. The relationship between Dave and Becky – Love and magic
In the first part, Becky Barnes (Teresa Palmer) was Dave’s young love. However, the film did not delve into how she reacted to finding out that Dave was a magician. In the next part, Becky could play a more important role.

An interesting theory is that Becky accidentally got drawn into the magical world, perhaps because she was targeted by a dark wizard or discovered that she had magical potential. This could create interesting conflicts, as Dave has to balance between love and responsibility to protect the magical world. Is Becky willing to become a witch to stand by Dave’s side, or will she leave him because she is afraid of supernatural powers?

4. Balthazar Blake Faces His Past
Balthazar has lived for centuries and was once a brilliant disciple of Merlin. However, his life certainly contains many mysteries that have not been revealed.

A potential plot for the second part is that Balthazar meets an old acquaintance – possibly a mage who was once his fellow student under Merlin’s tutelage. But instead of standing on the side of justice, this person may have followed the path of evil, using magic to manipulate time or reality. The confrontation between the two masters of magic will not only be an epic battle, but also a test of Balthazar’s faith and loyalty to Merlin’s ideals.

5. The Return of Horvath – The Arch-Villain Sorcerer
Maxim Horvath (Alfred Molina) is one of the most memorable villains of the first part. Although defeated, he is still alive. In a sequel, he could return with a vengeance plan, this time stronger and smarter.

Horvath could team up with Chernabog or an ancient magical force to defeat Balthazar and Dave. Or maybe he finds a way to steal magic from other wizards, making himself invincible. Horvath’s return would bring back familiar elements for fans and help expand the story with a new threat.

6. Expanding the Magical World – Unexplored Lands

The first part of The Sorcerer’s Apprentice introduced a vast but unexplored magical world. A sequel could take audiences to previously unseen mystical lands.

There could be an ancient temple that holds Merlin’s secrets, a magical city hidden in the modern world, or even a parallel dimension where magic reigns instead of science. The new settings would make the film more interesting and create more opportunities to explore mythical creatures, powerful artifacts, and untold legends.

7. Merlin’s Descendants – A New Generation of Mages
Merlin is one of the greatest wizards in history, but did he leave behind any descendants? One intriguing theory is that Dave or a new character is Merlin’s true descendant. This could explain why Dave has such special abilities in magic, or it could create a new conflict as a group of wizards seek to use Merlin’s descendants to carry out their plot to rule the world.

If the sequel focuses on building a new generation of mages, Balthazar could serve as the mentor, while Dave could become the one teaching magic to new students.

While The Sorcerer’s Apprentice 2 has not been confirmed, there are many potential directions the story could take. Whether it’s the rise of a powerful enemy like Chernabog, Dave’s development as a true mage, or the mysteries of Balthazar’s past, the sequel could deliver a more engaging, epic, and creative adventure.